SAMPLING & QUANTITIES

A makeup brush sample approval checklist for beauty brands

Record what was checked, under which conditions, and what still needs revision before moving from a sample to production.

What should I approve before bulk production begins?

Approve an identified sample and specification covering dimensions, materials, application, connections, finish, logo and packaging. Record review conditions, accepted details and unresolved revisions. Agree which checks cover every unit and which require selected samples or separate tests.

Compare the options and what to check
Review itemWhat to recordDecision before approval
Identity and dimensionsProduct code, drawing version, material specification and measurement points.Confirm the selected construction and any open dimensions.
ApplicationFormula, motion, amount and observations about pickup, placement and blending.Agree which result is acceptable for the intended use.
Connections and finishAlignment, gaps, loose fibres, colour and logo placement.Define acceptance criteria and any separately specified strength or wear test.
Care and shapeAgreed care procedure and the observed condition afterwards.Resolve changes in shape, fibre condition, finish or assembly.
Set and packagingContents, protective inserts, labels and packed sample.Approve the complete configuration rather than the brush alone.

Identify the sample being approved.

Give the sample a code and retain the associated drawing, finish reference, logo artwork and packaging version. Record proposed changes separately from accepted details. If a revised sample is needed, identify which version supersedes the previous one; a conversation such as “make it softer” is not a complete production instruction.

Use the intended formula and a repeatable review.

For a foundation brush, record the formula and examine placement, blending and remaining brush marks. For a powder brush, examine pickup, release and build-up. Define the application motion and review conditions so two samples can be compared fairly. This checklist proposes a review method; it does not report PRETTY test results.

Connect sample approval to the production process.

PRETTY’s process page sets out 28 recorded production steps, including head-shape and dimension checks, finishing inspections, full inspection and sampling inspection. Those stages show where checks fit into production. A stage name does not specify a pull force, a test cycle count or an acceptance limit: agree the method and criteria for your order.

Distinguish full inspection from a test on selected units.

Confirm which visible or measurable characteristics are checked on every brush and which tests use selected units. A strength or wear test may require a separate method and may be destructive. Ask how defects are recorded, what happens to nonconforming units and when a revised sample or corrective action is required.

Approve the packed product and keep the record.

Review the complete set contents, logo orientation, head protection and packaging with a physical sample. Record accepted details, requested revisions and unresolved items in one approval note. Production scope, quantities and timing should refer to that agreed version; an attractive sample photograph alone is not approval of every specification.

Use this in your sample review

Turn feedback into a revision the factory can act on

The examples below show how to write a review. They are proposed recording methods, not claims that PRETTY has passed a particular test or uses universal acceptance limits.

Swipe across the table to read all three columns.

Turn feedback into a revision the factory can act on
Initial feedbackA useful review instructionEvidence to retain
“It leaves lines.”Identify the sample, formula, product amount, application motion and the lines observed; compare the revision under the same conditions.Labelled photographs and the reviewed sample.
“Make it softer.”Describe whether the issue is tip feel, bending resistance, spread or the pressure required for the intended use.Accepted reference and notes on the comparison.
“The logo is wrong.”Identify the artwork version, location, orientation, size and the discrepancy from the approved version.Approved artwork and an annotated sample photograph.
“Ready for production.”List accepted details, rejected details and unresolved items before approving an identified revision.Signed or otherwise agreed approval record and specification.

Use explicit decisions for each review item.

Mark an item accepted, revision required, or not yet checked. A blank result is not approval. If approval is conditional, identify the condition and who must confirm it. Keep the commercial order scope and technical sample revision connected.

Separate a sample review from batch acceptance.

Approval of a sample establishes the agreed reference. It does not prove that every future unit matches it. Agree production inspection coverage, methods, defect handling and any sample-based tests separately; the 28-step process explains the sequence, not a statistical acceptance plan.

Sample approval and revision worksheet

A blank CSV for your own review. Open it in Excel or another spreadsheet app, complete it privately, and share it with your chosen supplier when ready. Nothing is submitted by downloading it.

Download the blank worksheet (CSV) ↓PRETTY · Template revised 2026-09-22 · Not a completed inspection or certification.

When is a sample ready for production approval?

A sample is ready for approval when the agreed checks are complete, the accepted version is identifiable and no unresolved issue affects the specification you are releasing. If a detail still needs changing, record the change and the evidence needed to close it. Avoid an unqualified “approved” message while revisions remain open.

Choose an explicit decision for each sample revision
DecisionRecordNext step
Approve the identified versionAccepted drawing, physical sample, artwork and packaging versions, plus agreed review results.Confirm the production release and commercial conditions in writing.
Request a revisionThe affected component, requested change and why the present sample does not meet the brief.Agree whether a revised physical sample or other evidence is needed before approval.
Keep approval on holdMissing information or an unresolved result, with an owner and next action.Close the issue before authorising production against that specification.

Does approving the brush also approve its packaging?

Only if the approval explicitly includes that packaging version. A loose brush does not demonstrate the fit of a sleeve, case or set insert. Check the packed sample separately, including head clearance, removal, logo orientation and the agreed contents.

What should be checked again after a revision?

Recheck the changed feature and anything it can affect. A new head dimension may change application and packaging clearance; a handle finish may change the appearance of the logo. Agree the scope of the repeat review rather than carrying every earlier result over to a different construction.

How should care instructions enter the review?

Record the cleanser, washing method and drying position used, then examine the dry sample for changes to shape, finish and connections. Sigma Beauty’s published care guidance cautions against excessive soaking and recommends drying brushes flat or at a slight downward angle. Treat this as general care context, not a validated procedure for every custom brush. Agree instructions for your selected materials and construction.

Source: Sigma Beauty’s brush-care guidance ↗. This reference does not certify PRETTY products or establish a business relationship.

What should the written approval say?

Identify the product code, sample revision and date; link the agreed drawing, material specification, artwork and packaging; record the checks completed and any exclusions. State who is approving the version and what production scope is authorised. Keep requested changes separate from accepted details.

For a two-ended design, review each end individually. See the UP068 packaging checks or the UP049 formula-review questions for product-specific starting points.

Include approval requirements in my enquiry →

Review shedding, streaks and assembly concerns before approval →

Questions before sampling

Turn the sample into an approval record

Keep accepted details, requested revisions and open decisions together.

What should I check before approving a custom makeup brush sample?

Check the identified drawing and materials, dimensions, intended application, connections, finish, logo, set contents and packaging. Separate accepted details from open issues and requested revisions. Approve an identified physical sample and written specification rather than an unversioned photograph.

Why should I test a brush with my intended makeup formula?

The formula affects what you observe during pickup, placement and blending. Testing with the intended product connects the sample decision to the customer's actual use. Record the formula, amount and motion so a revised sample can be assessed under comparable conditions.

How do I record a change request without ambiguity?

Use the sample code and version, identify the affected component and describe the required change with a measurement, reference or observable result. Include a marked photograph where helpful. Keep unchanged accepted features explicit so a revision does not unintentionally replace them.

What should a sample approval record include?

Include the sample ID, drawing and artwork versions, materials, review date, reviewer, checks performed and results. List accepted items, rejected items and unresolved questions, with the next revision if needed. Retain the packed configuration and agreed commercial scope alongside the technical approval.

Should I approve a brush and its packaging together?

Yes, when the order includes packaging. Insert every brush into the proposed case or box and check protection, fit, removal, labels and complete contents. Approval of a loose brush does not approve the packaging dimensions or prove that both heads of a dual-ended tool are protected.

How do I compare the first sample with a revised sample?

Keep both versions labelled and compare the requested changes under the same conditions. Recheck interfaces affected by the change, such as whether a larger head still fits the case. Record which revised version replaces the earlier reference and whether any items remain open.

Which defects should prevent approval of a brush sample?

Do not approve an unresolved defect that affects safe handling or an agreed requirement: examples include a sharp exposed edge, loose assembly, wrong material or missing set item. Appearance deviations also need an explicit decision. Define defect categories and acceptance criteria for the order instead of inventing a universal pass limit.

How do I retain an approved reference sample for a repeat order?

Label and retain the approved sample, drawing, artwork and packing specification with a revision date. Record storage conditions and any later changes. Before a repeat order, compare the retained reference and current specification, especially if materials, finish, packaging or the intended formula have changed.

What remains unconfirmed after approving a sample photograph?

A photograph can show visible appearance and placement, but not reliably prove feel, balance, hidden materials, connection strength or performance with a formula. Its scale may also be unclear. Identify which decisions remain open and review the physical sample before approving those properties.

How do I translate feedback such as softer into an actionable specification?

Explain whether the problem is tip feel, bending resistance, spread or pressure needed during application. Name the formula and motion and compare with an accepted reference if available. Review a revised sample and record the desired result; "softer" alone does not tell the factory which property to change.

Plan your next step

Ready to discuss your project?

Tell us which brushes you want to develop, how they will be used and what you would like to customise. Add the points from this guide to your enquiry so we can review the specification and sample requirements with you.

Bring PRETTY the sample code or revision and the changes you want to resolve. Use the worksheet to separate accepted details from revisions, so we can discuss the next sample and the specification for your proposed order.

Discuss your sample review with PRETTY →See where production checks fit

Apply this to your product brief.

Powder and foundation references need different application reviews even when they share checks for dimensions, connections, finish and packaging.

Compare BH01 / BK07 side by side →

Continue exploring

Contact PRETTY on WeChat

Scan this code in WeChat, or save the image and open it in WeChat.

PRETTY WeChat contact QR code

WeChat ID: 15532771438

Save QR image